A dutching calculator splits one total stake across two or more outcomes so you get the same return whichever of them wins. The sum behind it is short: divide 1 by each price, add those figures up, and give each outcome its share of your stake. On $50 across prices of $4.50 and $5.00, that is $26.32 and $23.68, and either winner returns $118.42. If neither wins, you lose the $50.
BetBank's free dutching calculator does that sum for 2 to 10 selections. This guide shows what it is doing, then covers the jobs a basic calculator doesn't: dutching for a set return, weighting a dutch towards one outcome, allowing for exchange commission, and lay dutching. Every price here is invented, and none of it is a tip.
What a dutching calculator does
Wikipedia describes dutching as "sharing the risk of losing across a number of runners by backing more than one selection in a race or event". The word comes from racing, but the maths works on any market where the outcomes can't both win: winning margin bands, three-way results, correct scores, top scorer markets.
The formula
For each selection:
- Implied chance = 1 / price.
- Book = the implied chances added together.
- Stake = total stake x implied chance / book.
- Return if it wins = total stake / book, the same for every selection in the dutch.
The book tells you how much of the market you're covering at those prices. If it's 45%, a winner pays back your stake divided by 0.45. One over the book is the combined price: the single price your whole dutch behaves like.
Example 1: two NBA winning margin bands
An invented NBA winning margin market, $50 to dutch two bands:
| Band | Price | Implied chance | Stake | Return if it wins |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Home by 1 to 5 | $4.50 | 22.22% | $26.32 | $118.42 |
| Home by 6 to 10 | $5.00 | 20.00% | $23.68 | $118.42 |
| Total | 42.22% | $50.00 |
Your combined price is $2.37 (1 / 0.4222). You are really making one bet: "the home team wins by 1 to 10". If you'd price that at better than 42% yourself, the dutch is worth a look. If not, splitting the stake doesn't change that. Our guide to NBA winning margin betting shows how those bands are priced in the first place.
Example 2: rebuilding a double chance on a Test match
A Test match can end in a draw as well as a win for either side, as the Wikipedia entry on cricket results sets out. That gives a three-way market, and dutching two of the three outcomes builds your own "double chance" bet.
Invented three-way prices:
| Result | Price | Implied chance |
|---|---|---|
| Home | $1.72 | 58.14% |
| Draw | $4.00 | 25.00% |
| Away | $5.00 | 20.00% |
| Book | 103.14% |
Dutching Draw and Away with $100:
| Result | Stake | Return if it wins |
|---|---|---|
| Draw | $55.56 | $222.22 |
| Away | $44.44 | $222.22 |
The combined price is $2.22. Now compare it with the bookmaker's own "Draw or Away" double chance market. If that shows $2.10, the dutch pays $12 more on the same $100, which tells you the double chance market is carrying more margin than the three-way. If it shows $2.30, take the double chance. The point is that a dutch gives you a second price to check against.
Dutching all three outcomes is a different story. The book is 103.14%, so $100 split three ways returns $96.96 whatever happens. That $3.04 is the bookmaker's margin, and our vig calculator guide shows how to work it out on any market.
Dutching for a set return
Some people would rather start from the return they want. That's even simpler: stake = target return / price.
For a $150 return on Draw and Away at $4.00 and $5.00:
- Draw: $150 / 4.00 = $37.50
- Away: $150 / 5.00 = $30.00
- Total staked: $67.50, so either winner returns $150, a profit of $82.50.
To do this with a total-stake calculator, enter any stake, note the return, and scale everything by your target over that return.
Weighting a dutch towards one outcome
A level dutch pays the same on every selection. Sometimes you'd rather break even on one outcome and keep all the profit on the other. Search for "advanced" or "unequal" dutching and this is usually what people mean.
The method:
- Pick the selection you only want to break even on.
- Its stake = total stake / its price.
- Put everything else on the selection you favour.
Back to the NBA bands with $50, breaking even on "Home by 6 to 10" at $5.00:
| Band | Price | Stake | Return if it wins | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Home by 1 to 5 | $4.50 | $40.00 | $180.00 | $130.00 |
| Home by 6 to 10 | $5.00 | $10.00 | $50.00 | $0.00 |
Same $50, same two outcomes, a different shape of result. It doesn't change the value of either bet, only where the payout lands.
Dutching on an exchange: allow for commission
On an exchange you can back several outcomes the same way, but you pay commission on what you win. Betfair Australia says each market has a Market Base Rate, "the maximum percentage of your winnings that you will pay in commission", and that the rate for sport and international racing markets is 6%, except NRL at 10%.
The stakes don't change
A level dutch wins the same amount whichever selection wins, so the commission is the same whichever wins too. Use the normal formula on the exchange prices and every outcome still comes out level after commission.
The price you really get does
To compare an exchange price with a bookmaker's, convert it:
Effective price = 1 + (exchange price - 1) x (1 - commission rate)
At 6%:
| Exchange price | Effective price after 6% |
|---|---|
| $4.20 | $4.01 |
| $4.30 | $4.10 |
| $5.20 | $4.95 |
| $5.40 | $5.14 |
So an exchange price of $4.20 on the draw is worth about the same as a bookmaker's $4.00. You'd need around $4.30 before the exchange is clearly better. Our guide to Betfair commission goes deeper on how the rate is charged.
Lay dutching
Lay dutching is the reverse: you lay two or more outcomes on an exchange. You lose the same amount if any of them wins, and you collect your lay stakes if anything else wins.
The surprise is that the stake formula is the same. Each lay stake is proportional to 1 / its lay price. That keeps your loss level across every outcome you laid.
Laying Draw at $4.20 and Away at $5.20 on the invented Test match, with lay stakes of 100 / price:
| Lay | Lay price | Lay stake | Liability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Draw | $4.20 | $23.81 | $76.19 |
| Away | $5.20 | $19.23 | $80.77 |
- Draw wins: you pay $76.19 and keep the $19.23 Away stake, so you're down $56.96.
- Away wins: you pay $80.77 and keep the $23.81 Draw stake, so you're down $56.96.
- Home wins: you keep both stakes, $43.04, or $40.46 after 6% commission.
Risking $56.96 to win $40.46 is an effective price of about $1.71 on Home. That's the second surprise: laying everything except Home is the same bet as backing Home. If the exchange offers Home at $1.76 to back, its effective price after 6% is also about $1.71. Lay dutching is useful when lay prices are tighter than back prices, or when you want to oppose a few outcomes in a big field. It isn't a different kind of edge.
Watch the liabilities. Each one is bigger than the amount you can win, so a lay dutch can tie up a lot of your balance for a small return. BetBank's back and lay calculator handles a single back and lay with commission if you're working one outcome at a time.
Dutching, arbitrage and matched betting
These overlap, so it helps to keep them apart:
| Approach | What you cover | When it loses |
|---|---|---|
| Dutch | Some outcomes, sized for the same return | Any outcome you didn't cover wins |
| Arbitrage | Every outcome, at prices adding to under 100% | Only if something goes wrong: a price moves, a bet is voided, rules differ |
| Bookmaker-only cover | Every outcome across bookmakers, prices adding to over 100% | Always loses a little: the amount over 100% |
The "matched betting dutching calculator" searches are usually about the third row: covering every outcome with bookmakers instead of laying on an exchange. The book tells you the cost. At 103.14% on our Test match, covering all three results costs about 3% of the stake. Find a combination of prices from different bookmakers under 100% and it becomes an arbitrage, which our arbitrage calculator guide covers.
What a calculator can't tell you
- Whether the dutch is good value. A dutch's expected value is the stake-weighted average of each selection in it. Poor prices make a poor dutch. Our earlier post, dutching explained, works through this for racing, including scratchings and deductions.
- Whether every leg will be accepted. Prices move. If one leg is rejected or shortened, the dutch is no longer level. Place the hardest-to-get price first.
- Market rules. Check how each bookmaker settles the market, especially overtime in basketball and abandoned or shortened matches in cricket.
A quick dutching checklist
- Add up 1 / each price. That's your book and the share of the market you're covering.
- Work out the combined price and ask whether you'd take that price on the outcomes together.
- On a three-way market, compare your dutch with the double chance price.
- Convert exchange prices to their effective price after commission before comparing.
- Take the best price for each leg, even across different bookmakers.
- Decide your total stake before you open the calculator.
Work out your next dutch
Put your prices into BetBank's free dutching calculator to get the stakes, the level return and the book in one go. To find the best price for each leg first, the odds screen lines up prices across Australian bookmakers side by side.
18+ only. Every dutch can lose and no calculator changes that, so set a limit and gamble responsibly. If you want a break from online betting, BetStop is the free national self-exclusion register.